2017 Call
http://www.boe.es/boe/dias/2017/12/16/pdfs/BOE-A-2017-14907.pdf
Assessment criteria
General Legislation National Committee for Evaluating Research Activity (CNEAI)
http://www.mecd.gob.es/ministerio-mecd/organizacion/organismos/cneai/legislacion.html
EC3metrics (2014). Course "Cómo preparar con éxito la solicitud de sexenios de investigación CNEAI: principios e indicadores". Comillas Pontifical University. Delivered by Daniel Torres Salinas and Álvaro Cabezas Clavijo.
Consult the journals' impact index, position, and quartile in the ranking for its specialty. Journals are sorted from greatest to lowest impact factor, and are divided into 4 quartiles (Q1, Q2, Q3, Q4)
Journal Citation Reports (JCR)
SCImago Journal & Country Rank (SJR)
Potential Impact Factor of Spanish Medical Journals
Google Scholar Metrics (GSM) Journal Scholar Metrics Art, Humanities, and Social Science
Google Scholar Metrics of Spanish scientific journals (2012-2016)
Journals without a relative quality score
Master Journal List (Thomson) Scopus Journal List CIRC (also in Dialnet) ERIH PLUS DICE (Product not updated) RESH Journals with the Spanish Science and Technology Foundation (FECYT) seal of quality (2016) LATINDEX Website of the journal
See:
Web of Science Core Collection: (Cited Reference Searching) Science Citation Index (1900- ); Social Sciences Citation Index (1956- ); Arts & Humanities Citation Index (1975- )
RESH ERIH PLUS MIAR Indexing in international databases: Dialnet WoS Scopus ; presence in catalogs
SPI List of Publishers - Book Citation Index (Clarivate Analytics) IE-CSIC (Índice de Editoriales CSIC) Dialnet WoS Scopus
Series Seal of quality : Series Seal - CEA
Citations received: WoS Scopus Google Scholar Google Books
Reviews: Dialnet Google Scholar Google Books
National Committee for Evaluating Research Activity (CNEAI)
This evaluates the research activity of university academic staff and the personnel of the Spanish National Research Council's academic scales, with the aim of a productivity bonus being recognized for them (six year research cycle).
National Quality and Accreditation Agency (ANECA)
A state organization with the aim of contributing to improving the quality of the higher education system through the evaluation, certification, and accreditation of courses, academic staff, and institutions.
Aggregates the meaningful connections of citations created by the research community through the delivery of a rich array of publisher-independent data, metrics and analysis of the world’s most impactful journals included in the Science Citation Index Expanded (SCIE), Social Sciences Citation Index (SSCI), Arts & Humanities Citation Index (AHCI), and the Emerging Sources Citation Index (ESCI).
Access online from 1997. Access
Is a ratio which divides a journal’s received citations by a count of its published articles.
Editions:
A category-normalized metric calculated for all journals in the Web of Science Core Collection, including the Science Citation Index Expanded, Social Science Citation Index, Arts & Humanities Citation Index, and Emerging Sources Citation Index • Another impact metric, complementing the Journal Impact Factor, that helps you assess journal performance with added context.
Developed by the SCImago group using data from Scopus. This includes a series of academic indicators for journals and countries.
It has two metrical indices: SJR and SNIP (Source-Normalized Impact per Paper): this measures the contextual impact of citations weighting them in accordance with the total number of citations in a given subject area. Useful for research areas with a lower probability of citations
Prepared by the López Piñero History of Science and Documentation Institute. Its main aim is to identify the national and international IF of Spanish biomedical journals.
Analysis of citations of documents included in Repec. It includes a ranking with the IF of journals and working documents.
This provides an impact index for academic journals, measured according on their h-index, making it possible to consult the hundred most cited journals in the world by language of publication. Spanish journals are ordered according to the h-index calculated between the years 2007-2011. The most cited articles from each particular journal can also be seen. Journals published in English allow consultations by areas and disciplines.
Bibliometric tool that seeks to measure the performance of Art, Humanities, and Social Science journals by counting the number of bibliographic citations their articles have received according to Google Scholar.
GSM mainly covers scientific journals (~95% of the sources). The rest of the sources are conference proceedings (mostly from Computer Science and Engineering), and collections in repositories (i.e. arXiv, SSRN). Only journals, conference proceedings, or repository collections which have published at least 100 papers in the last five complete years and received at least one citation are included in this product.
There are two bibliometric indicators computed for every journal: the H5-index (h-index computed from the citations to documents published in the last five years) and the H5-median (median of the citation counts in the documents that contribute to the H5-index).
A ranking carried out by the EC3 Group to overcome the limitations of GSM. It organizes the Spanish journals that appear in GSM by academic field and discipline and orders them by the h-index. Its aim is to test Google Scholar Metrics' breadth of coverage of Spanish academic journals.
Comillas Library offers a Service to support teaching and research staff in their activities. personalized help , video tutorials, Guides and Workshops.
The research support services will be attended through Servicio de Atención al Usuario de Biblioteca – Apoyo a la investigación (CAU)
Producing academic works
Publication and dissemination of Academic Work
Evaluation research
La Biblioteca recomienda seguir la normativa que se utiliza el catálogo de la biblioteca
https://biblioteca.comillas.edu/digital/abnetopac.exe/
Consultar Perfil de los investigadores e investigadoras de la Universidad y al catálogo de su producción científica. En construcción
En ella se respeta la decisión del propio autor:
Se indican ambos apellidos seguidos de una coma y el nombre completo del autor más preposiciones que acompañen al primer apellido, o preposiciones y artículos.
Ej. Apellido Apellido, Nombre1 Nombre2
Martínez Martínez, Julio Luis
En el catálogo de autoridades de la biblioteca están reflejados todas las variantes de los nombres de autor recogidas en las distintas bases de datos, perfiles e identificadores.
Los índices de citas recopilan información sobre las citas bibliográficas que se realizan en los artículos académicos. Ello hace posible saber las citas recibidas por un autor o por un trabajo concreto.
Una de las medidas de calidad que se tiene en cuenta para evaluar la actividad de los investigadores es la cantidad de citas que recibe un artículo o un trabajo.
Más información consultar: Indices de citas
Índice formulado por J. Hirsch en 2005. Sistema de medición de la calidad profesional de los científicos. Mide las publicaciones de un investigador individual.
Se calcula midiendo la distribución de las citas que han recibido los trabajos científicos de un investigador.
Un científico tiene índice h si el h de sus trabajos recibe al menos h citas cada uno.
Entre los recursos que ofrecen el índice h destacamos:
It is recommended to choose a signature form that clearly distinguishes us from other researchers.
A standardized signature facilitates the recognition of authorship, avoiding name confusion in publications, databases and research and academic platforms.
Always include the Institutional Affiliation:
Universidad Pontificia Comillas
Author identifiers are meant to help with author name disambiguation. In order to measure your impact as an author, you want to be sure you get credit for all your research output. Publishing under variations of your name, having a common name, changing your name, changing institutions - all of these can lead to your work being incorrectly associated with another author, or you can end up with several author profiles.
ORCID: Open Research & Contributor ID An international and interdisciplinary organization. This provides researchers with a register to obtain a unique and permanent identifier that distinguishes them from any others. It enables the attribution of academic works. |
![]() |
|
Publons Use Publons to track your publications, citation metrics, peer reviews, and journal editing work in a single, easy-to-maintain profile. • All your publications, instantly imported from Web of Science, ORCID, or your bibliographic reference manager (e.g. EndNote or Mendeley). • Trusted citation metrics, automatically imported from the Web of Science Core Collection. • Correct author attribution, with your unique ResearcherID automatically added to the publications you claim in Web of Science collections. |
![]() |
|
Scopus Author ID Scopus automatically generates an author identifier for authors in the Scopus database and attempts to disambiguate authors and build an author profile. Citation metrics are included with each author profile. You cannot edit your author profile yourself, but you can request corrections if publications are incorrectly assigned (or missing from) your profile or you find other errors. |
![]() |
|
Google Scholar Citations Set up an author profile in Google Scholar Citations and you can view citation metrics for your publications and get an email alert every time one of your publications is cited. |
![]() |
|
Dialnet ID |
![]() |
|
You can request to the Library the unification of your signature or the way your name is indexed in the databases Centro de Atención a usuarios de Biblioteca (CAU).
The purpose of these recommendations are:
The library criteria is to recommend using the the rules of the library catalog.
Available at:https://biblioteca.comillas.edu/digital/abnetopac.exe/O7049/ID181353e3?ACC=101
See also,Comillas Authors records teaching and research staff (PDI)at:
Available at:
https://biblioteca.comillas.edu/autoridades/abnetopac.exe/O7003/ID23c4406c?ACC=101
Once staff have decided on a signature, they should not change it unless iti is absolutely necessary. The same format should be used for national and international publications.
Eg. Last name1 , last name2, first name1 first name
Martínez Martínez, Julio Luis
in the library Authorities catalog we can find the different variants of the author’s name,collected in the different databases, authors profiles, and identificators.
This establish common standards when signing academic works with the aims of helping with preparing bibliographies. For standardizing authors and institutions and recommendations for electronic addresses and websites. (versión completa)
Standardized signature system for scientific authors. Helps authors to compile bibliographies
Composición del comité científico encargado de la revisión de las colaboraciones, y los evaluadores externos.
El proceso de "peer review" (revisión por pares) para el control de calidad de un artículo.
Libros y capítulos de libros, se valorará que estén publicados en editoriales de reconocido prestigio, así como la colección en la que aparezca la obra, y el proceso de selección de originales
Para seleccionar una editorial y solicitar la publicación de un trabajo de investigación, conviene informarse sobre las editoriales de prestigio, los mejores editores, y el proceso de selección. Existen unos sistemas y herramientas para la valoración del prestigio editorial:
Búsca cualquier ISSN el sistema localizará en qué bases de datos de las contempladas en la matriz está indizada la revista, esté recogida o no en MIAR, y calculará su ICDS.
Además ofrece información de la presencia de la revista en repertorios de evaluación: el Sello de Calidad FECYT, Scimago Journal Rank, CARHUS+ o CIRC, así como la política de acceso abierto recogida en el color ROMEO.
Objetivo: es la construcción de una clasificación de revistas científicas de Ciencias Sociales y Humanas en función de su calidad integrando los productos de evaluación existentes considerados positivamente por las diferentes agencias de evaluación nacionales como CNEAI, ANECA.
Desarrollado por AGAUR (Agència de Gestió d'Ajusts i de Recerca).
Listado de revistas científicas de calidad de ciencias sociales y humanidades con visibilidad local, nacional e internacional.Clasificadas en 4 categorías
Creada por el Grupo de Investigación Evaluación de Publicaciones Científicas en Ciencias Sociales y Humanas y el IEDCYT (CSIC). ANECA utiliza esta base de datos como referencia de calidad de las publicaciones españolas, en sus procesos de evaluación de profesorado.
Los indicadores son los siguientes: evaluadores externos, Bases de datos, valoración de la difusión, apertura exterior de los autores, internalización de las contribuciones, número de criterios Latindex, Categoría ANEP, Categoría ERIH
Sistema de información que integra indicadores de calidad para las revistas científicas españolas de Ciencias Sociales y Humanidades. Ha sido desarrollado en el marco del proyecto Valoración integrada de las revistas españolas de Ciencias Sociales y Humanas.
Dirigido fundamentalmente a editores de revistas, investigadores, bibliotecarios y evaluadores de la actividad científica en estas áreas.
Los indicadores que ofrece e integra esta plataforma son, por una parte, Criterios de calidad: CNEAI, ANECA y Latindex tienen en cuenta en sus respectivos sistemas de evaluación; difusión; opinión de expertos; impacto
proyecto del Departamento de Traducción e Interpretación y el personal de la Biblioteca de Humanidades de la Universidad Autónoma de Barcelona, recoge la lista de revistas científicas en el área del conocimiento de Traducción e Interpretación con los indicadores de calidad de los diferentes recursos evaluados por los organismos de acreditación: AQU, ANECA y CNEAI. Además, incluye enlaces a varios catálogos bibliográficos, requisitos para la publicación de artículos de acuerdo con el editor y los permisos para el auto-archivo en un repositorio institucional y científico.
Los títulos incluidos en el Catálogo han sido seleccionados y clasificados por cada país socio, según criterios internacionales de calidad editorial previamente probados y convenidos por el Sistema Latindex.
Proyecto impulsado por la European Science Foundation. Listado de revistas de de calidad en 14 especialidades dentro del ámbito de las humanidades.
Objetivo aumentar la visibilidad de las revistas europeas punteras en humanidades
incluyen aquellas revistas indexadas simultáneamente en REDIB y en los diferentes índices de la Web of Science Core Collection: Science CItation Index (SCI), Social Sciences Citation Index (SSCI), Arts & Humanities CItation Index (A&HCI) y Emerging Sources Citation Index (ESCI). El periodo de cobertura utilizado para medir las variables que conforman el ranking es el año al que corresponde la edición y los cinco anteriores, es decir, seis años completos. El objetivo es proporcionar una información lo más completa posible de la influencia y el impacto de las revistas que cumplan las condiciones de indexación antes descritas.
A project by the Spanish National Research Council's (CSIC) ILÍA Group.
An information system that offers indicators and tools relating to academic publishers or publishers of interest for research in the fields of the humanities and the social sciences. The results are intended to provide an objective answer, or help to provide an objective answer, to the “prestige of the publisher” indicator used by evaluation agencies.
There is a general ranking and a ranking by disciplines
The list of academic publishers that Thomson Reuters selects for the Book Citation Index.
Prepared by EC3Metrics, this provides indicators for analyzing research in monographs and academic publishers included in the Book Citation Index. Study and analysis of citation patterns in books and book chapters from academic publishers. It provides indicators for publishers in 4 large fields and 38 disciplines. It provides the following bibliometric indicators:
A bibliometric index created by the EC3 research group (Evaluation of Science and Scientific Communication)
This aims to measure the impact of the publishers of academic monographs by counting the citations of books published by academic staff and researchers from Spanish public universities indexed in Google Scholar up to 2012 in the fields of the humanities and social sciences.
This project started out with the aim of satisfying and responding to the demand by the agencies that evaluate academic activity (CNEAI, ANEP, ANECA) to evaluate the performance of publishers and the books they publish.
These agencies regard the following as preferential criteria: the number and quality of citations received; the prestige of the publisher; the editors; the collection in which it is published; reviews in specialist academic journals; translations; inclusion in bibliographies.
This tool provides a response to the first two variables: the number and quality of the citations.
29 series have obtained the Seal of quality. Eight of them have also achieved special mentions of internationality.
The seal is promoted by the Spanish Union of Academic Publishers (UNE) and endorsed by the National Quality and Accreditation Agency (ANECA) and the Spanish Science and Technology Foundation (FECYT).
A search for any ISSN in the system will find amongst the databases included in the matrix in which the journal is indexed, whether it is included in MIAR or not, and will calculate its ICDS (Composite Secondary Dissemination Index).
It also provides information about the journal's presence in evaluation registers: the Spanish Science and Technology Foundation (FECYT) seal of quality, Scimago Journal Rank, CARHUS+, and CIRC, as well as the open access policy reflected by the ROMEO color.
Objective: the creation of a classification of academic journals in the social sciences and humanities according to their quality, integrating the results of existing positive evaluations by the different national evaluation agencies such as CNEAI and ANECA.
Developed by AGAUR (Agència de Gestió d'Ajusts i de Recerca - Agency for Managing Meetings and Research).
A list of quality academic journals in the social sciences and humanities with local, national, and international visibility. Sorted into 4 categories
Created by the Grupo de Investigación Evaluación de Publicaciones Científicas en Ciencias Sociales y Humanas and the IEDCYT (CSIC). ANECA uses this database as a quality reference for Spanish publications in its academic staff evaluation processes.
The indicators are as follows: external evaluators; databases; evaluation of dissemination; external profile of the authors; insourcing of the contributions; number of Latindex criteria; ANEP category; ERIH category
An information system that integrates quality indicators for Spanish academic journals in the social sciences and humanities. It has been developed within the framework of the Integrated Evaluation of Spanish Social Science and Humanities Journals project.
It is primarily intended for editors of journals, researchers, librarians, and evaluators of academic activity in Spain.
The indicators that this platform offers and integrates are, in part, quality criteria: CNEAI, ANECA, and Latindex take dissemination, expert opinions, and impact into account in their evaluation systems.
The titles included in this catalog have been selected and classified by each partner country according to international criteria of editorial quality previously tested and agreed by the Sistema Latindex.
A project promoted by the European Science Foundation. A list of quality journals in 14 specialties within the scope of the humanities.
Its aim is to increase the visibility of the leading European journals in the humanities.
REDIB journals also indexed in WoS Core Collection, we will extract citation metrics over a rolling six-year period of time (each iteration analyzing citations from the latest full year to the previous five years) For all overlap journals, we would include citation counts and links with journals in the other segments of the WoS Core collection (Science Citation Index-Expanded, Social Sciences Citation Index, Arts & Humanities Citation Index, Emerging Sources Citation Index) to create the most complete picture of journal influence and impact possible.
This compiles information on the proceedings of international conferences, colloquia, and seminars since 1990.
Conference database created by the Centro Informático Científico de Andalucía.
This brings together conferences, colloquia, seminars, lectures, and in general any event held in Spain or in any other related part of the world.
Conference ranking by the Computing Research and Education Association of Australasia
A report prepared by the EC3 research group. Evaluación de la Ciencia y de la Comunicación Científica-Universidad de Granada. Índice H de Actas de Congresos en Informática e Ingeniería Eléctrica y Electrónica y de las Comunicaciones según Google Scholar Metrics.
A successful academic social network, with 14 million users.
It aims to put researchers in touch with others who have the same interests, grouping them by body, department, and subjects of interest. It also provides access to full texts, specialist mailing lists, and job offers.
Researchers can create a web page about their research, upload work, find colleagues and acquaintances through Facebook, LinkedIn, and Gmail, and follow the work of other researchers.
They can set up alerts for news about their subject or journals of interest.
A social network for researchers, it allows the creation of a profile and access to interest groups, forums, related literature.
It has a semantic search engine for academic journal articles - over 35 million entries, it navigates through internal and external research resources in the main databases (PubMed, CiteSeer, arWiv)
Over 5 million members (including 30 Nobel laureates), 190 countries.
A toolkit for helping to use those kinds of sites more effectively to maximize visibility of research work. Explain your work in plain language - this will make it easier for potential readers to find and understand it.
Use your custom Kudos link to share your work – via email, social media, academic networks or elsewhere - to let people know you have published. Kudos brings together a “basket of metrics” including citations, downloads and Altmetrics (tracking discussion of your work in a range of places including press coverage, social media and government policy.)
A new metric based on Web 2.0 measuring the impact of an article using different indicators such as downloads, citations in Wikipedia, tweets, retweets, people saving the article in a citation manager.
Altmetrics. (2016, May 14). In Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Retrieved 09:46, May 25, 2016, from https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Altmetrics&oldid=720266020
The terms "altmetrics" (alternative metrics) and "article level metrics" have been used to describe approaches to measure the impact of scholarship by using new social media tools such as bookmarks, links, blog postings, inclusion in citation management tools and tweets to gauge the importance of scholarly output.
Proponents of altmetrics believe that using altmetrics will help measure the impact of an article in a more comperhensive and objective way thaa was done perviously with journal metrics databases like Journal Citation Reports. However, there are limits to this approach and caution should be used to not rely on any one particular measure in evaluting the importance of scholarship.
Guides.library.harvard.edu. (2016). Altmetrics / Other Metrics - Citation Analysis - Research Guides at Harvard Library. [online] Available at: http://guides.library.harvard.edu/c.php?g=311134&p=2073443 [Accessed 25 May 2016].
Altmetrics guide. Library University of Seville
The score donut visualisation tells you at a glance how much attention has been paid to an article, as well as which sources the mentions have come from.
Aggregator of impact data for sources such as Mendeley, Wikipedia, Delicious, Facebook, Google+, Twitter
This uses Mendeley data to analyze the impact of publications by a particular author.
This enables researchers to monitor the comments and criticisms made on their academic works. It also enables anyone to review works in an open and transparent setting.
Databases that compile information about the bibliographic citations made in academic articles.
It makes it possible to know the number of citations received by an author or a specific piece of work.
The first three citation indexes contain the references cited by the authors of the articles. You can use these references to do cited reference searching.
Science Citation Index Expanded (SCI-Expanded) -- 1900-present
Social Sciences Citation Index (SSCI) -- 1900-present
Arts & Humanities Citation Index (A&HCI) -- 1975-present
Emerging Sources Citation Index (ESCI) -- 2015-present
Elsevier database containing the citations of works it has published since 1996.
Analysis of citations of documents included in its database.
This gives information about the citations received by the journals in the database itself.
A database created by the Spanish National Research Council and the Carlos III University of citations in Spanish on modern history. Objective: Analysis and evaluation of citations in academic journals and conference proceedings.
A search engine including peer-reviewed studies, theses, books, abstracts, and articles from academic sources. In the results it provides information about the number of citations received.
Databases that also provide information on citations generated by the articles.
Books / chapters from
Reviews
A search for any ISSN in the system will find amongst the databases included in the matrix in which the journal is indexed, whether it is included in MIAR or not, and will calculate its ICDS (Composite Secondary Dissemination Index).
It also provides information about the journal's presence in evaluation registers: the Spanish Science and Technology Foundation (FECYT) seal of quality, Scimago Journal Rank, CARHUS+, and CIRC, as well as the open access policy reflected by the ROMEO color.
This includes information about the databases in which each journal is indexed.
This has one section: dissemination linked to the name of the specific databases that contain that publication, as well as with the information from the database, such as the producer, its thematic and temporal coverage, and the applicable publication selection criteria.
Access to journals indexed by Elsevier for Scopus and Thomson Reuters for WoS
Joint catalog of the network of university libraries
The largest catalog in the world. This stores data, records, and entries for more than 71,000 public and private libraries around the world.
A bibliometric index that aims to measure the dissemination and visibility of publishers of academic books in the fields of the humanities and social sciences by counting the books included in the catalogs of the Spanish university and academic libraries that make up the REBIUN catalog.
Copyright guide Ministry of Education, Culture and Sport
Information on intellectual property. Ministry of Education, Culture and Sport